If all our personal experience of the universe is in a very real sense only within our minds (for what other experience can we have?)...
If pleasure is a state of mind to be sought, one to be valued (even if displeasure is a sometimes necessary and often useful state of mind that among other things gives value to pleasure, and also prods us to actions that allow us to continue living and pursuing pleasure)...
Then should we perhaps recognize that a primary source of pleasure derives from the simple fact that we exist and have some means of exploring what exists (ourselves and everything else), creating richer analogies, making further sense of what we perceive?
Each intelligent being has different capabilities and tendencies of thought, but all can experience the complexity of existence and enjoy it in their own way. I am not ignoring the fact that many people are forced into life circumstances that make it almost impossible to enjoy even the most basic facets of existence. I suspect this may be true in similar numbers for many other intelligent animals. My point is perhaps akin to the phrase "pursuit of happiness" in the U. S. Declaration of Independence, in that I think it would be a laudable goal to seek this as a right for all sentient beings, even though it is likely virtually impossible in an animal kingdom that has evolved through ceaseless competition for survival. Predators are not going to lie down peaceably with prey, but people do not need to mistreat animals that they consider inferior, or have decided have no sensibilities and exist only for our purposes. Even more certainly, people do not need to mistreat other people. Of course, they will - we too have evolved characteristics that tend toward our own preservation at the expense of others - but we have the intelligence to see beyond this, to see above this. An idealist's goal has to be to work toward a world where those who are able to make judgments rationally can exert more influence than those whose every action is dictated by aggrandizement and individual self-preservation instincts born of a time long past.
I was thinking of these things as I watched our young dog Ziva clearly deriving enormous pleasure from simple acts - running, eating, gnawing, smelling, looking at new objects, playing tug of war, resting on a soft surface, and so forth. I would like to think that I have taught myself to enjoy much of what life has to offer, but there is still much for me to learn from a fellow traveler like Ziva. Along the way, I find that I greatly enjoy sensing her happiness. Sharing positive emotions can increase their power for both parties!
Permalink: http://jilcp.blogspot.com/2014/10/drawing-pleasure-from-simple-fact-of.html